Online Now 3116

The Blue Board

We aren't just committed to college football; we're early enrolling in it.

On this Board 2172
Record: 7394 (2/14/2012)

Online now 2903
Record: 18710 (2/25/2012)

Boards ▾

The Blue Board

We aren't just committed to college football; we're early enrolling in it.

The Green Board

Where the madness isn't just in March.

Big Ten Board (Beta)

Reply

Best classes by position- offense

  • star69 said...

    Homerlol actually I agree if/when Dawson recommits. Texas offered 2 of those kids as DL I do believe. Heck, looking like Robinson ends up at USC. I'd put your OL class at the top with Dawson and ours #2..

    That's the thing - I think our class is close with just the current 4 v. 4, but if/when Robinson decommits, and if/when Dawson recommits, I don't think there's a better OL group in the country than Michigan's.

    signature image signature image signature image

    CMXI ●

  • CMXI said...

    That's the thing - I think our class is close with just the current 4 v. 4, but if/when Robinson decommits, and if/when Dawson recommits, I don't think there's a better OL group in the country than Michigan's.

    We're also in line to get the #1 JuCo Tackle, and Billings who we offered as dlineman but could play center/guard down the line.

    signature image signature image signature image

    Canadianhorn ●

  • #2 qb and now #2 juco qb. I'll take it.

    signature image

    #DicedPineapples

    shavisimo2 ●

  • shavisimo2 said...

    #2 qb and now #2 juco qb. I'll take it.

    Have to think this puts us with the top QB class, ratings of 99 and 91. All in a day's work.

    signature image

    psubills62 ●

  • Bump.... I guess we'll have to settle for the #2 juco QB instead

    This post was edited by ejb5212 on 12/15/2012 at 7:21 AM

    attachment
    signature image

    'Just to make it clear, I'm not transferring, I like it here too damn much to leave.' Jordan Kerner

    ejb5212 ●

  • getmyjive11 said...

    So if PSU gets Waters, would they be bumped up to #1 for QBs?

    Would have been, hands down.

    National Director of Scouting & Recruiting Analyst @GerryHam247

    Gerry Hamilton ●

  • psubills62 said...

    Have to think this puts us with the top QB class, ratings of 99 and 91. All in a day's work.

    I would definitely agree. As its a JUCO for immediate impact along with a big time HS prospect.

    That is an ideal combo IMO.

    National Director of Scouting & Recruiting Analyst @GerryHam247

    Gerry Hamilton ●

  • xxmgobluexx said...

    What about the oline part of the question JC? Michigan adding Dawson.

    Definitely possible, and Texas is in a battle to hold onto A'Shawn Robinson - who we project on the OL long term.

    National Director of Scouting & Recruiting Analyst @GerryHam247

    Gerry Hamilton ●

  • JurrassicBuck,I said...

    Goodness, A&M's class is stacked.

    Texas A&M and Georgia because of the combo of talent and numbers are very impressive from a very likely # of future starters perspective. Good players, and a lot of of them - both still with room to add 2-3 more impact guys to the classes.

    National Director of Scouting & Recruiting Analyst @GerryHam247

    Gerry Hamilton ●

  • Dawson's back in!

    Crown us! lol

    signature image signature image

    Clarkw267 ●

  • Clarkw267 said...

    Dawson's back in!

    Crown us! lol

    Lol.

    That's why it's fun to these types of articles now and again on signing day.

    Big get for Michigan, for many reasons, but very well may get crowned - barring Texas getting Desmond Harrison.

    National Director of Scouting & Recruiting Analyst @GerryHam247

    Gerry Hamilton ●

  • Gerry Hamilton said...

    Lol.

    That's why it's fun to these types of articles now and again on signing day.

    Big get for Michigan, for many reasons, but very well may get crowned - barring Texas getting Desmond Harrison.

    I'm assuming one of the many reasons is his relationship with Green. It makes too much sense for him to come to Michigan which is why I'm worried he won't end up here.

    signature image signature image

    Clarkw267 ●

  • Gerry Hamilton said...

    I would definitely agree. As its a JUCO for immediate impact along with a big time HS prospect.

    That is an ideal combo IMO.

    thumbsup

    Especially when you've only got one scholarship QB currently on the roster.

    signature image

    psubills62 ●

  • psubills62 said...

    thumbsup

    Especially when you've only got one scholarship QB currently on the roster.

    lol Yeah, I forgot that little key part of the equation.

    National Director of Scouting & Recruiting Analyst @GerryHam247

    Gerry Hamilton ●

  • Ducksworth said...

    If we get Dawson, we can make a heck of a line.

    LT: Logan Tuley-Tillman LG: Kyle Bosch C: Patrick Kugler RG: David Dawson RT: Chris Fox

    I have a hard time seeing any line better than that, personally.

    Of course you don't just as I don't see an OL class better than ND's

    signature image signature image signature image

    WE ARE ND76

  • WE ARE ND76 said...

    Of course you don't just as I don't see an OL class better than ND's

    Let's play the game by 247's rankings

    Bivin 95 > Tuley-Tillman 94
    Elmer 91 < Bosch 94
    McGlinchey 90 < Fox 94
    Montelus 90 < Dawson 94
    McGovern 90 < Kugler 93

    Now by Composite

    Bivin .943 < Kugler .960
    Elmer .937 < Bosch .957
    Montelus .934 < Fox .948
    McGovern .927 < Dawson .943
    McGlinchy .902 < Tuley-Tillman .925

    I'd say we have a winner....

    Now Texas with Robinson is still the best... but Michigan > ND

    signature image signature image

    Clarkw267 ●

  • WE ARE ND76 said...

    Of course you don't just as I don't see an OL class better than ND's

    Yeah except the analysts agree with me shrug

    signature image signature image signature image

    Ducksworth ●

  • Clarkw267 said...

    Let's play the game by 247's rankings

    Bivin 95 > Tuley-Tillman 94 Elmer 91 < Bosch 94 McGlinchey 90 < Fox 94 Montelus 90 < Dawson 94 McGovern 90 < Kugler 93

    Now by Composite

    Bivin .943 < Kugler .960 Elmer .937 < Bosch .957 Montelus .934 < Fox .948 McGovern .927 < Dawson .943 McGlinchy .902 < Tuley-Tillman .925

    I'd say we have a winner....

    Now Texas with Robinson is still the best... but Michigan > ND

    Elmer and Montelus are better than any 2 OL in Michigan's class I don't care what 247's ranking says. Elmer and Montelus' composite score is skewed by ESPN's absurd ranking of both players. They are both great OL classes and probably #1 and #2 imho. I'm taking ND's OL class over Michigan's. Time will tell who is right.

    signature image signature image signature image

    WE ARE ND76

  • Just a reminder, Desmond Harrison can have a big impact on top OL class (if he picks Texas), and the #1 spot in the team rankings (if he picks USC). Not counting Oklahoma out at all, but he can really impact those two from the position and team rankings.

    National Director of Scouting & Recruiting Analyst @GerryHam247

    Gerry Hamilton ●

  • WE ARE ND76 said...

    Elmer and Montelus are better than any 2 OL in Michigan's class I don't care what 247's ranking says. Elmer and Montelus' composite score is skewed by ESPN's absurd ranking of both players. They are both great OL classes and probably #1 and #2 imho. I'm taking ND's OL class over Michigan's. Time will tell who is right.

    roflmao

    So you don't care what this site's experts think, or what any other expert thinks. You are going with the one site that suits ND. Gotcha.

    This post was edited by Clarkw267 on 12/16/2012 at 7:55 PM

    signature image signature image

    Clarkw267 ●

  • Clarkw267 said...

    roflmao

    So you don't care what this site's experts think, or what any other expert thinks. You are going with the one site that suits ND. Gotcha.

    I'm disagreeing with their ranking on Elmer and Montelus and I have all season long. Obviously I value 247's opinions or I wouldn't subscribe to the site. For that matter I think they have Bivin overrated on the OL but that is just my opinion. All sites get some right and some wrong and I think 247 has Montelus and Elmer underrated. We are allowed to have differing opinions. It's what makes have sports debates/discussions fun.

    signature image signature image signature image

    WE ARE ND76

  • So even with Dawson recommitting before the OP came out, Michigan still isn't the top? The two way player from Texas may play on the other side of the ball and then you only have 3 players on the OL.

    Although, looking at the commits for the other classes considered, almost all of them could be in that spot. Glad you guys make that call and take the backlash from the cut-throat fans.

    UMichYank11 ●

  • You have to like PSU's chances at the best QB class. If anyone thought that a year ago at this time I would like you to pick my lottery numbers from now on.

    Itzsessil ●

Football Recruiting
Basketball Recruiting
Features
Resources
Connect

247Sports In partnership with CBS Sports