In partnership with CBSSports.com
We aren't just committed to college football; we're early enrolling in it.
Where the madness isn't just in March.
You have no favorite boards.
The most viewed topics.
The most replied to topics.
The most up-voted topics.
The most down-voted topics.
The most up-voted posters.
The most down-voted posters.
The most followed posters.
There is literally nothing Tebow does (or did) on a football field better than Cam Newton.
Yes, Tebow had a longer college football career.
No, none of his years as a starter come close to Cam's single year as a starter.
in college thomas played in a 3-4.
i was a classmate of his.
every list must have:
hugh green at pitt
lawrence taylor unc.
john hannah and dwight stephenson on the o line. and munoz
hershell and bo at rb.
reggie white on d line.
ray guy punter
Jake Long never gave up a sack either, and he only allowed one penalty his whole career at UM. I still put Boselli over him. LT has had some GREAT players over the years, and you can make cases for a lot of them.
with the tackles he has, i don't think samuels would be able to unseat them, but he was a beast.
dwight stephenson at c should be considered. AA at bama, all-sec, coach bryant called him the best player he ever coached, regardless of position. many consider him the best center all time. 5x pro bowl, 5x all-pro, nfl hof.
cornelious bennett at lb should be considered. 3x AA (all 1st team), 3x all sec, SEC DPOY, lombardi winner, heisman finalist, cfb HOF, 5x pro bowl, 3x all pro, 2x afc DPOY, soon to be nfl hof
and finally, if your going by just talent, then this one is a no, but if your going for importance to the game and stats, then maybe.
don hutson - AA, cfb HOF, 2x nfl MVP, nfl HOF, green bay HOF, held 18 nfl records at end of career, most for decades including career rec tds and season rec tds for 40+ years, some still stand, credited with creating the modern wr position and routes, lean nfl in receptions for 8/11 seasons, including 5 straight, lead nfl in rec yards 7 seasons, including 4 straight, and lead nfl in scoring 5 straight seasons. also played both ways, and lead nfl in interceptions a couple times. #9 player of all time by nfl.com, nfl all-time team (75th anny).
nice list, i've been skimming and it's past my bed time.
someone mentioned no ronnie lott. he was a beast, throw in steve atwater from arkansas as well.
johnny rodgers for pr over the rocket.
pretty much have to keep the list post 1960 as well.
both woodsons in the secondary were beasts.
Ronnie Lott was a safety in college, right? Either way, safety or CB, I like my choices.
You have got to be kidding about Emitt over Walker?I am a die hard Cowboy fan and Emitt is my favorite Cowboy ever.But he couldn't be a pimple on Hershel's ass in college.Hershell was unstoppable at Georgia.You must be like 20 or something.
Who is the other slot WR you would have then? I know you like Warrick, but who would be your SWR backup on this list?
Anthony Carter, from Michigan.
This post was edited by CRgator1 23 months ago
So THE only guy with 2 heismans does't get first or second team?...lol
I can understand if we're talking about college stats/nfl potential, but no way Archie should not be first team if we're talking about strictly their college careers.
ECU grad, tOSU fan for life. Father since 1/12/13.
You're either bias or crazy (probably both) if you think Archie should be chosen over Herschel or Barry.
This post was edited by Rabid 23 months ago
I guess hesiman voters are crazy too.
But, like i said, before i make a true judgment, are these strictly based on entire college careers?....one season?.....2 seasons?....or college careers and NFL greatness/potential?
Yes, this list took no consideration from what they did in their NFL careers. I thought that was obvious from who I have as my QB. (And a lot of other positions, fwiw.) SMH...
And yeah... You're definitely delusional. Archie is NOT on Herschel or Barry's level.
Ryan Broyles? And...someone ahead of Barry Sanders?
So if you go by college careers, and THE only 2 time heisman (aka best player in the country) winner is not even in the 2 deep.....that means i'm delusional? Good stuff.
Don't deny at all that Herschel and Barry were more talented, but college career wise they weren't.
It seems like I'm taking a lot of heat for Broyles.. Fine, I'll change that.
Barry was not better than Herschel in college, though.
You're not invited. I thought you stopped posting for good?
Can you do a favor for me?
Absolutely. I love m*chigan fans....
Please, make a thread and ask tBB who they think is better. Herschel or Archie.
Can't do...NWO/SEC honks would take over...anything else I can do?
Barry had the greatest season in college football history.
247Sports In partnership with CBS Sports