In partnership with CBSSports.com
We aren't just committed to college football; we're early enrolling in it.
Where the madness isn't just in March.
You have no favorite boards.
The most viewed topics.
The most replied to topics.
The most up-voted topics.
The most down-voted topics.
The most up-voted posters.
The most down-voted posters.
The most followed posters.
That's why I was so appalled b/c people don't respect the all-time rushing leader in TD's and yards, yet everyone gives the entire credit to the O-line but when Smith held out we were 0-2 and not the same team..
It's the only empirical data I have that the Cowboys were w/o Smith, if I didn't mean anything Jerry wouldn't have caven in like he did..
This post was edited by jmsmooth33 20 months ago
He's certainly not a person to cave when it comes to other people's opinions for sure. I respect Emmitt immensely. I just don't think he's the best RB to ever play the game by far. I think he's top ten though.
I didn't say he was the GOAT just don't understand how people always call him overrated..
Yeah I don't think he's the best ever by any means but he sure as hell isn't overrated.
Danielle Hunter, Jamario Rasco, Anthony FREAK Johnson.. DL wrecking crew of 2013.
I agree and wouldn't call him overrated. I would actually call him underrated. I mean he's the all time leading rusher and doesn't get near the credit he deserves. Overrated is a stretch in the least.
LOL underrated every cowboy fan I know thinks E.Smith is g.o.a.t
Well I'm not a Cowboy's fan and don't know a whole lot of them. I can only go by what I hear personally.
Thought it would have included [when watching them in college]
Emmitt Smith is NOT overrated. He was a great RB. Watched him run for 220+ as a true freshmen against a Bama defense with Derrick Thomas. Also watched his high school film. Baller at every level he played.
This post was edited by BamaBornDukie 20 months ago
You get out of it what you put into it!
Are you asking about other RB's above Emmitt?
I would put OJ along with the three you listed as the top four
Personally I think the following are right about in the same category as far as rankings:
Ok? No one said anything about Smith being the best.. Just saying he's not overrated.
Based on his numbers he's the best.
True but he's not the best of all time, IMO.
Earl Campbell needs to be somewhere in this list.
Also, though, like Sayers, his career was cut too short by injury, I will go to my grave knowing that, when healthy, Billy Sims was among the very best RBs I ever saw
Same with Bo Jackson though.
Him and Herschel Walker were the best true talented RB's to ever play that I have ever seen. Bo Jackson was like Jim Brown IYAM had he not had that hip injury.
Emmitt Smith reminds me a lot of Mark Ingram.
I know that Mark Ingram is young, but that is an insult to Emmitt.
Ingram is a 3rd stringer and will never touch Emmitt Smith as a pro player.
This post was edited by RATT 20 months ago
That was a joke about all those national guys who couldn't talk about MI without referencing the Man, Emmitt. I hate the Gator but ES is one of my all time favorite players.
Don't take it the wrong way.
It's not like I'm pissed about it or anything. Just saying that Mark Ingram, love the dude to death, isn't anywhere near bringing into a discussion with ES. I do somewhat understand what you are saying though. Not the fastest guy, not the most athletic, he just gets it done. I wish he would have been drafted by anyone but the Saints though.
That pick never made any sense to me whatsoever. Put him on a team like the Giants, Cardinals, 49er's or a team that actually likes to run the ball, and he would actually be able to make some noise.
In the right situation MI could have had a more Emmitt like career. Just wait till MI eventually has a big game. The talking heads will start bring up all the ES references again.
Stop with this homerism.. Ingram would not have a "more like Emmit career" on another team. He's a lifetime #2 RB
This is correct.. Obviously would have had the rushing record had he not retired.
Just take a look at his junior year at Oklahoma State.
This post was edited by Clarkw267 20 months ago
247Sports In partnership with CBS Sports