Online Now 3055

The Blue Board

We aren't just committed to college football; we're early enrolling in it.

On this Board 2259
Record: 7394 (2/14/2012)

Online now 4049
Record: 18710 (2/25/2012)

Boards ▾

The Blue Board

We aren't just committed to college football; we're early enrolling in it.

247Rumors

College football scuttlebutt and scoop- powered by Football Rumor Mill

The Green Board

Where the madness isn't just in March.

Big Ten Board (Beta)

Reply

Could someone give me the Rivals - 247 History?

  • MSU's site, Spartantailgate (aka, the Red Cedar Message Board or RCMB), has been largely independent over it's 15+ year history. We joined up with ESPN briefly before ultimately going with 247. As a result, myself and the other RCMB posters are kind of in the dark about the Rivals/247 history and split.

    I realize one of the Rivals founders decided to leave and create 247; Sports Illustrated now uses 247's rankings, etc. Reading your posts, Rivals/247 was founded by Alabama fans? Any heads up would be appreciated.

    On a side note, I truly enjoy the free-roaming, tailgate-esque feel that 247 has. It's great to be able to pop over to the Nebraska and Wisconsin sites and get their opinions on the upcoming season. I kind of wish that all the sites were open to posting to VIP members of another 247 site; sucks that I can't talk to Ohio State fans on their board, because our programs have a lot of ties and we recruit OH well. That aside, it's been a solid new environment for the MSU contingent (all 27 billion of us).

    Michigan State does not and will not run the 3-4 defense.

    SpartanRocky

  • SpartanRocky said...

    MSU's site, Spartantailgate (aka, the Red Cedar Message Board or RCMB), has been largely independent over it's 15+ year history. We joined up with ESPN briefly before ultimately going with 247. As a result, myself and the other RCMB posters are kind of in the dark about the Rivals/247 history and split.

    I realize one of the Rivals founders decided to leave and create 247; Sports Illustrated now uses 247's rankings, etc. Reading your posts, Rivals/247 was founded by Alabama fans? Any heads up would be appreciated.

    On a side note, I truly enjoy the free-roaming, tailgate-esque feel that 247 has. It's great to be able to pop over to the Nebraska and Wisconsin sites and get their opinions on the upcoming season. I kind of wish that all the sites were open to posting to VIP members of another 247 site; sucks that I can't talk to Ohio State fans on their board, because our programs have a lot of ties and we recruit OH well. That aside, it's been a solid new environment for the MSU contingent (all 27 billion of us).

    the guy that created rivals, Lucky sold rivals and left a couple years ago. had to wait out his non compete clause and then founded 247. now 247 is killing rivals and taking rivals' largest subscription based teams (bamaonline was largest on rivals network).

    signature image

    10 Major Poll National Titles (CFB record) 35 Bowl Wins (CFB record) 61 Wins over last 5 years (CFB record)

    coolstorybro

  • coolstorybro said...

    the guy that created rivals, Lucky sold rivals and left a couple years ago. had to wait out his non compete clause and then founded 247. now 247 is killing rivals and taking rivals' largest subscription based teams (bamaonline was largest on rivals network).

    Is Lucky a Bama guy? Just like to know my biases [wink]

    Michigan State does not and will not run the 3-4 defense.

    SpartanRocky

  • SpartanRocky said...

    Is Lucky a Bama guy? Just like to know my biases [wink]

    Yeah he's a bama fan

    This post was edited by coolstorybro on 5/11/2011 at 11:52 AM

    'Lucky' right name for founder of Rivals.com - al.com

    http://www.al.com/news/huntsvilletimes/local.ssf?/base/news/1251710163109240.xml&coll=0

    www.al.com
    signature image

    10 Major Poll National Titles (CFB record) 35 Bowl Wins (CFB record) 61 Wins over last 5 years (CFB record)

    coolstorybro

  • coolstorybro said...

    Yeah he's a bama fan

    Gotcha. I take it there's some bitterness between the two companies now? Who runs Rivals now? And why the hell is it so hard to get a Midwest analyst!

    Michigan State does not and will not run the 3-4 defense.

    SpartanRocky

  • SpartanRocky said...

    Gotcha. I take it there's some bitterness between the two companies now? Who runs Rivals now? And why the hell is it so hard to get a Midwest analyst!

    A lot of bitterness. Lucky basically built Rivals and now is building the company that beats Rivals

    signature image

    10 Major Poll National Titles (CFB record) 35 Bowl Wins (CFB record) 61 Wins over last 5 years (CFB record)

    coolstorybro

  • coolstorybro said...

    A lot of bitterness. Lucky basically built Rivals and now is building the company that beats Rivals

    Thanks for the heads up. I assume you're a Bama fan by your avatar. I appreciate the insight; I've got nothing against Rivals per se, save for the fact they STILL don't have a Midwest analyst. No doubt that Rivals is going to come crashing down in a few years; glad to be a part of 247.

    Michigan State does not and will not run the 3-4 defense.

    SpartanRocky

  • SpartanRocky said...

    Gotcha. I take it there's some bitterness between the two companies now? Who runs Rivals now? And why the hell is it so hard to get a Midwest analyst!

    He sold Rivals to Yahoo Sports. However their team sites are interdependently owned and operated. Tidesports.com for example, is owned and operated by the Tuscaloosa News.

    signature image signature image signature image

    Phoenix427

  • coolstorybro said...

    A lot of bitterness. Lucky basically built Rivals and now is building the company that beats Rivals

    No bitterness on this end. A lot of guys over there that we are still very friendly with. But get it straight, this is a competition and they are our competitors. We're coming after them and I like our chances.

    Barton Simmons | 247Sports | National Recruiting Analyst | Twitter: @bartonsimmons

    Barton S

  • Barton S said...

    No bitterness on this end. A lot of guys over there that we are still very friendly with. But get it straight, this is a competition and they are our competitors. We're coming after them and I like our chances.

    Haha, no problem. Like I said, tRCMB has been largely independent, so we've got zero loyalty to Rivals (other than the fact I think their rankings have been historically better than Scout or ESPN, so we tend to use their star rankings when talking about past classes). We're a 247 board now, and it looks like one of the top 2-3 on here. As I've said, glad to be a part of it.

    Michigan State does not and will not run the 3-4 defense.

    SpartanRocky

  • SpartanRocky said...

    Haha, no problem. Like I said, tRCMB has been largely independent, so we've got zero loyalty to Rivals (other than the fact I think their rankings have been historically better than Scout or ESPN, so we tend to use their star rankings when talking about past classes). We're a 247 board now, and it looks like one of the top 2-3 on here. As I've said, glad to be a part of it.

    We're excited to have you on board. As far as the rankings go, keep in mind that a lot of the guys that have been putting together those rivals rankings in the past (myself, JC Shurburtt, Gerry Hamilton, Bobby Burton) are over here now. The only guys over there that remain that have been involved in the rankings in the past are Mike Farrell and Barry Every. The rest are new to the process so hopefully you'll give our rankings a fair shake.

    Barton Simmons | 247Sports | National Recruiting Analyst | Twitter: @bartonsimmons

    Barton S

  • ilovelamp51 said...

    they havent changed with the times, 247 did. its going to get nasty for them the next year or so. posters use to have nowhere else to go & put up w/ being treated like crap, not anymore.

    What do you mean by "put up with being treated like crap"? What was it like over there?

    Michigan State does not and will not run the 3-4 defense.

    SpartanRocky

  • SpartanRocky said...

    What do you mean by "put up with being treated like crap"? What was it like over there?

    Up until recently the analysts never answered questions. Even noe when you do you get talked down to by them.

    Mods would ban at random for apparently no reason

    Etc.....

    Aussie

  • SpartanRocky said...

    What do you mean by "put up with being treated like crap"? What was it like over there?

    About 18 months ago, there was a switch from the way it had worked on the board back then, to the way it is now. In the past, there were 5 or so poster-mods who would lock threads, delete posts, delete threads, etc. They were accountable for the way they operated, and answered for their actions. Things were fine.

    Right about after the 2008 season, a large group of longtime Rivals posters felt that the censorship on the board had become too great. They broke away and formed their own board, the-mainboard.com. This board you could post porn, curse, basically do whatever the hell you wanted, but they still had some non-juvenile discussion over there. It's just a bit overwhelming.

    With that crew, the last poster mod resigned. So Rivals, in their infinite wisdom decided to create two new poster mod positions, but not tell anyone who they were. They were simply designated, mod no 1 and mod no 2.

    Enter the Vols, Bitch crowd. A small, but loud group of trolling Tennessee fans who after Kiffin was hired took over the board for nearly a year. Why this is important? This group outed a current poster of this board as mod no 1. That was pretty much the end of the poster mod.

    With that came threads getting deleted and locked without explanation. People would be banned for minor infractions for long periods of time. Emails for reinstatement and questions about the way things were being handled went unanswered.

    Then came the Jeff Lee posting a posters personal information in an article saga. Rivals refused to address that as well.

    Basically what happened, is that over time, the level of customer service deteriorated to an almost prisoner level. You never found out why things were happening, you simply had to accept that they were.

    signature image signature image signature image

    phoenixtidegrad

  • PTG nailed it.

    Aussie

  • phoenixtidegrad said...

    About 18 months ago, there was a switch from the way it had worked on the board back then, to the way it is now. In the past, there were 5 or so poster-mods who would lock threads, delete posts, delete threads, etc. They were accountable for the way they operated, and answered for their actions. Things were fine.

    Right about after the 2008 season, a large group of longtime Rivals posters felt that the censorship on the board had become too great. They broke away and formed their own board, the-mainboard.com. This board you could post porn, curse, basically do whatever the hell you wanted, but they still had some non-juvenile discussion over there. It's just a bit overwhelming.

    With that crew, the last poster mod resigned. So Rivals, in their infinite wisdom decided to create two new poster mod positions, but not tell anyone who they were. They were simply designated, mod no 1 and mod no 2.

    Enter the Vols, Bitch crowd. A small, but loud group of trolling Tennessee fans who after Kiffin was hired took over the board for nearly a year. Why this is important? This group outed a current poster of this board as mod no 1. That was pretty much the end of the poster mod.

    With that came threads getting deleted and locked without explanation. People would be banned for minor infractions for long periods of time. Emails for reinstatement and questions about the way things were being handled went unanswered.

    Then came the Jeff Lee posting a posters personal information in an article saga. Rivals refused to address that as well.

    Basically what happened, is that over time, the level of customer service deteriorated to an almost prisoner level. You never found out why things were happening, you simply had to accept that they were.

    Holy $&%^

    I had no idea it was that bad. On tRCMB, we've had 8-12 poster mods just for our fanbase, plus a language filter (till the 247 switch, prefer to have one, FWIW) and no porn. I can't imagine 2 mods for 40+ fanbases. Wow, I'm glad I never signed up for MSU's Rivals site. . . . yeesh.

    Michigan State does not and will not run the 3-4 defense.

    SpartanRocky

  • SpartanRocky said...

    Holy $&%^

    I had no idea it was that bad. On tRCMB, we've had 8-12 poster mods just for our fanbase, plus a language filter (till the 247 switch, prefer to have one, FWIW) and no porn. I can't imagine 2 mods for 40+ fanbases. Wow, I'm glad I never signed up for MSU's Rivals site. . . . yeesh.

    We have 4 user mods just for this board and as it stands right now is half the size of rivals. Whoever has been making the decisions at rivals in the last year has not done a very good job.

    Aussie

  • Yikes. People are serious about their message boards.

    Stils

  • Dbl was mod number 1.

    Also almost every former mod of the rivals board now are active members of the-mainboard.com

    that site averages approx 300,000 page views a day.

    considering its run by two former posters on rivals and funded purely from poster donations, its been quite the success.

    Although many older posters from various sites seem to think its a bunch of teenagers. The average age of a poster on the-mainboard is around 23. With the oldest poster being in his 60's and the youngest around 16.

    MB7

  • MB7 said...

    Dbl was mod number 1.

    Also almost every former mod of the rivals board now are active members of the-mainboard.com

    that site averages approx 300,000 page views a day.

    considering its run by two former posters on rivals and funded purely from poster donations, its been quite the success.

    Although many older posters from various sites seem to think its a bunch of teenagers. The average age of a poster on the-mainboard is around 23. With the oldest poster being in his 60's and the youngest around 16.

    I wasn't hating on your board. I still check it out from time to time. It's just not an all the time kinda place for me.

    signature image signature image signature image

    phoenixtidegrad

  • MB7 said...

    Dbl was mod number 1.

    Also almost every former mod of the rivals board now are active members of the-mainboard.com

    that site averages approx 300,000 page views a day.

    considering its run by two former posters on rivals and funded purely from poster donations, its been quite the success.

    Although many older posters from various sites seem to think its a bunch of teenagers. The average age of a poster on the-mainboard is around 23. With the oldest poster being in his 60's and the youngest around 16.

    I didn't know that about dbl. TMB is a really good site. 1,000,000x better than Rivals.

    Aussie

  • SpartanRocky said...

    MSU's site, Spartantailgate (aka, the Red Cedar Message Board or RCMB), has been largely independent over it's 15+ year history. We joined up with ESPN briefly before ultimately going with 247. As a result, myself and the other RCMB posters are kind of in the dark about the Rivals/247 history and split.

    I realize one of the Rivals founders decided to leave and create 247; Sports Illustrated now uses 247's rankings, etc. Reading your posts, Rivals/247 was founded by Alabama fans? Any heads up would be appreciated.

    On a side note, I truly enjoy the free-roaming, tailgate-esque feel that 247 has. It's great to be able to pop over to the Nebraska and Wisconsin sites and get their opinions on the upcoming season. I kind of wish that all the sites were open to posting to VIP members of another 247 site; sucks that I can't talk to Ohio State fans on their board, because our programs have a lot of ties and we recruit OH well. That aside, it's been a solid new environment for the MSU contingent (all 27 billion of us).

    FYI, Spartan Tailgate was part of Rivals 1.0 (as I call it) for a couple of years before that iteration of Rivals went belly up. Many people forget about that era in Rivals history. We were offered to rejoin but decided to go the independent route after Rivals reformed and Shannon and the other guys came in. That choice had nothing to do with them though.

    This post was edited by Trevor Barnes on 5/11/2011 at 2:46 PM

    Trevor Barnes

  • SpartanRocky said...

    MSU's site, Spartantailgate (aka, the Red Cedar Message Board or RCMB), has been largely independent over it's 15+ year history. We joined up with ESPN briefly before ultimately going with 247. As a result, myself and the other RCMB posters are kind of in the dark about the Rivals/247 history and split.

    I realize one of the Rivals founders decided to leave and create 247; Sports Illustrated now uses 247's rankings, etc. Reading your posts, Rivals/247 was founded by Alabama fans? Any heads up would be appreciated.

    On a side note, I truly enjoy the free-roaming, tailgate-esque feel that 247 has. It's great to be able to pop over to the Nebraska and Wisconsin sites and get their opinions on the upcoming season. I kind of wish that all the sites were open to posting to VIP members of another 247 site; sucks that I can't talk to Ohio State fans on their board, because our programs have a lot of ties and we recruit OH well. That aside, it's been a solid new environment for the MSU contingent (all 27 billion of us).

    Also, I can't personally speak to the details in this story, but it talks quite a bit about the history of Rivals, 247 and Scout. I believe that the author is a contributor on the 247 OSU Bucknuts site.

    This post was edited by Trevor Barnes on 5/11/2011 at 2:51 PM

    Ex Rivals Founder Shannon Terry Looking to Challenge Rivals, Scout, and ESPN with College Recruiting Network 2.0, 24/7 Sports

    http://benkoo.com/articles/biz-and-tech/ex-rivals-founder-shannon-terry-looking-to-challenge-rivals-scout-and-espn-with-college-recruiting-network-20.html

    benkoo.com

    Trevor Barnes

  • SpartanRocky said...

    No doubt that Rivals is going to come crashing down in a few years..........

    If that happens, I will laugh my ass off. I was at Rivals for 5 years because I couldn't find a worthwhile alternative. When 24/7 came along, the decision to finally leave them was easy.

    signature image
    signature image
    signature image

    GetHooked

  • Lucky is the alpha and omega of recruiting web sites is the short answer.

    signature image

    natalex85