Online Now 3152

The Blue Board

We aren't just committed to college football; we're early enrolling in it.

On this Board 1870
Record: 7394 (2/14/2012)

Online now 3275
Record: 18710 (2/25/2012)

Boards ▾

The Blue Board

We aren't just committed to college football; we're early enrolling in it.

247Rumors

College football scuttlebutt and scoop- powered by Football Rumor Mill

The Green Board

Where the madness isn't just in March.

Big Ten Board (Beta)

Reply

FSU fans, Hamilton>Jimbo?

  • Has done more with less. Plays tougher competition.

    Discuss.

    signature image signature image signature image

    It's Great to be a Florida Gator! Recruit. Develop. Perform.

    gatordmb89

  • Florida State's basketball team is loaded with talent too.

    Xavier Gibson was a 5-star until his injury in high school, re-evaluated as a 4-star after

    Michael Snaer was the 7th overall player in the entire country, and a McDonald's AA

    Bernard James was one of the top JUCO players in the country

    Luke Loucks and Devidas Dulkys both were 4-stars and Top 150 prospects

    Ian Miller was a Top 50 player, and made John Wall his biaaaatch in the state championship his Jr year

    Jon Kreft was a 5-star out of high school, and a 4-star after JUCO

    etc etc etc

    signature image

    BushidoNole

  • Yes, and FSU's football classes under Jimbo, have been better than the recent basketball classes. Combine that with playing tougher competition, and I think FSU has a better basketball coach than football coach ATM.

    signature image signature image signature image

    It's Great to be a Florida Gator! Recruit. Develop. Perform.

    gatordmb89

  • Just looking at the roster now...

    Michael Snaer - 5 star - 7 in top 150
    Xavier Gibson - 4 star - 56 in the top 150
    Ian Miller - 4 star - 62 in top 150
    Okaro White - 4 star - 67 in the top 150
    Deividas Dulkys - 4 star - 69 in the top 150
    Luke Loucks - 4 star - 86 in the top 150
    Antwan Space - 4 star - 91 in top 150
    Terry Whisnat - 4 star - 103 in top 150
    Terrance Shannon - 3 star - 132 in top 150

    Bernard James - 4 star - JUCO
    Jon Kreft - 4 star - JUCO
    Kiel Turpin - 3 star - JUCO

    Jeff Peterson - Arkansas transfer

    signature image

    BushidoNole

  • BushidoNole said...

    Just looking at the roster now...

    Michael Snaer - 5 star - 7 in top 150 Xavier Gibson - 4 star - 56 in the top 150 Ian Miller - 4 star - 62 in top 150 Okaro White - 4 star - 67 in the top 150 Deividas Dulkys - 4 star - 69 in the top 150 Luke Loucks - 4 star - 86 in the top 150 Antwan Space - 4 star - 91 in top 150 Terry Whisnat - 4 star - 103 in top 150 Terrance Shannon - 3 star - 132 in top 150

    Bernard James - 4 star - JUCO Jon Kreft - 4 star - JUCO Kiel Turpin - 3 star - JUCO

    Jeff Peterson - Arkansas transfer

    Good talent, no doubt. However, look at the talent of UNC, Duke, etc. Then look at other teams in the ACC in football besides FSU. Talent doesn't stack up at all from other ACC football schools. FSU blows everyone away easily in terms of recruiting talent.

    signature image signature image signature image

    It's Great to be a Florida Gator! Recruit. Develop. Perform.

    gatordmb89

  • I think the better assessment is Jimbo is the best football coach in Florida.

    TheOriginalBigL

  • TheOriginalBigL said...

    I think the better assessment is Jimbo is the best football coach in Florida.

    Disagree. None have won any type of Championship, and that's all that matters.

    All of them are extremely average IMO.

    signature image signature image signature image

    It's Great to be a Florida Gator! Recruit. Develop. Perform.

    gatordmb89

  • I think Jimbo is doing alright...

    19 wins in two season
    2-0 against UF
    2-0 against Miami
    2-0 in bowl games (USCe, ND)
    back-to-back Top 3 recruiting classes

    Anyone with common sense [few among ANY fan base], and people in Tallahassee, have had 2012 pegged as the year Florida State gets back into the national picture. We were talking about 2012 at the end of the 2010-11 season. If our OL comes together this off-season, which I think they will, then we will easily win 10 games, and have a strong chance at the ACC championship.

    I said before last season that we would only win 9 games, and lose to at least two people we had no business losing to. That was just because you could see in the spring how mediocre this line [OL] would be, and I didn't trust EJ to be 100% dialed in, despite having 9 career starts before Ponder left in the 1st round under Jimbo's guidance.

    shrug

    That's just me though..

    I can't speak for others like NoVa, fsufsu, and all the other Florida State fans that visit TBB.

    Will Jimbo become an illustrious HC like Nick Saban? I don't think so, unless he hands over the play calling duties one day to a legitimate offensive coordinator. I think he will be a guy who can keep us in the top 15, have us flirt with a national championship opportunity [It's the ACC after all...] every couple of years, and stock the cabinent full with talent from 1st to scout team.

    Which means that if Jimbo does not work out, then the next coach will come into a loaded program, much like Urban Meyer did once Ron Zook was canned.

    signature image

    BushidoNole

  • I agree with all of that. Still though, 2-0 against UF and Miami isn't that impressive right now. Both programs currently are garbage. Sorry, but a win against ND isn't very impressive. The win against SCe is semi impressive. We will see how it goes this year for FSU, but it's not like Jimbo took over a bunch of scrubs at FSU either. He has recruited very well, but Hamilton has recruited very well as you have shown, and now has some type of Championship. I agree though, Jimbo is doing "alright". I expect FSU to dominate the ACC though, so we shall see.

    signature image signature image signature image

    It's Great to be a Florida Gator! Recruit. Develop. Perform.

    gatordmb89

  • BushidoNole said...

    I think Jimbo is doing alright...

    19 wins in two season 2-0 against UF 2-0 against Miami 2-0 in bowl games (USCe, ND) back-to-back Top 3 recruiting classes

    Anyone with common sense [few among ANY fan base], and people in Tallahassee, have had 2012 pegged as the year Florida State gets back into the national picture. We were talking about 2012 at the end of the 2010-11 season. If our OL comes together this off-season, which I think they will, then we will easily win 10 games, and have a strong chance at the ACC championship.

    I said before last season that we would only win 9 games, and lose to at least two people we had no business losing to. That was just because you could see in the spring how mediocre this line [OL] would be, and I didn't trust EJ to be 100% dialed in, despite having 9 career starts before Ponder left in the 1st round under Jimbo's guidance.

    shrug

    That's just me though..

    I can't speak for others like NoVa, fsufsu, and all the other Florida State fans that visit TBB.

    Will Jimbo become an illustrious HC like Nick Saban? I don't think so, unless he hands over the play calling duties one day to a legitimate offensive coordinator. I think he will be a guy who can keep us in the top 15, have us flirt with a national championship opportunity [It's the ACC after all...] every couple of years, and stock the cabinent full with talent from 1st to scout team.

    Which means that if Jimbo does not work out, then the next coach will come into a loaded program, much like Urban Meyer did once Ron Zook was canned.

    This.

    No one with any knowledge of our program really thought we were an elite team this past year prior to the season. The timetable among most knowledgeable FSU fans was that 2012 would be our best shot at doing something nationally. I disagree with one thing. I think that in Jimbo's offense, our OL will have to be very good. If that happens, the sky is the limit.

    TheOriginalBigL

  • CartierGator said...

    I agree with all of that. Still though, 2-0 against UF and Miami isn't that impressive right now. Both programs currently are garbage. Sorry, but a win against ND isn't very impressive. The win against SCe is semi impressive. We will see how it goes this year for FSU, but it's not like Jimbo took over a bunch of scrubs at FSU either. He has recruited very well, but Hamilton has recruited very well as you have shown, and now has some type of Championship. I agree though, Jimbo is doing "alright". I expect FSU to dominate the ACC though, so we shall see.

    UF seemed to thump their chests an awful lot when they were beating up on pitiful FSU teams. Funny how that becomes no big deal when the tables have turned.

    TheOriginalBigL

  • TheOriginalBigL said...

    UF seemed to thump their chests an awful lot when they were beating up on pitiful FSU teams. Funny how that becomes no big deal when the tables have turned.

    It wasn't a big deal to me then, and it's not a big deal to me now. FSU sucked then, and UF is no good right now. I'm a realist when it comes to UF or what many UF fans would consider a negaGator. I'm waiting for some 90's matchups again where both teams are elite.

    signature image signature image signature image

    It's Great to be a Florida Gator! Recruit. Develop. Perform.

    gatordmb89

  • CartierGator said...

    I agree with all of that. Still though, 2-0 against UF and Miami isn't that impressive right now. Both programs currently are garbage. Sorry, but a win against ND isn't very impressive. The win against SCe is semi impressive. We will see how it goes this year for FSU, but it's not like Jimbo took over a bunch of scrubs at FSU either. He has recruited very well, but Hamilton has recruited very well as you have shown, and now has some type of Championship. I agree though, Jimbo is doing "alright". I expect FSU to dominate the ACC though, so we shall see.

    UF and Miami might not be up to the old school days of UF and Miami, but there is still talent on both rosters. The Canes had 9 players invited to the NFL combine. Urban Meyer had how many top 10 recruiting classes? Who's fault is it that those players aren't producing wins? Just like you can't put the blame on Jimbo, because the classes that Bobby Bowden, and his dumbass assistants brought in, went to complete waste.

    Just because you sign a 4 or 5-star doesn't guarantee them glory in college. Those 4 and 5-star kids needs to come in with a 2-stars work ethic, and then those coaches have to be competent, and know how to develop the kids to reach their potential. That's what Florida State was lacking before Jimbo took over HC. You still had Chuck Amato coaching LB's. You still had Jody Allen coaching DE's. You still had Mickey running a 1970's cover 0 scheme. Get where I'm going with this?

    The attitude of the program was set to mediocrity, because the coaches before Jimbo allowed it. They yelled at kids, they didn't coach kids. Nobody evolved from a coaching staff perspective, and college football passed them by. There's a new attitude in Tallahassee, and it was showing last season, just watch how our defense played, and [when our OL blocked] on offense.

    But dont confuse my optimism and enthusiasm for the future as me saying "WE WINNING SHIPS IN 2012", because I am waiting to see how the OL and EJ do in the Spring going up against the best defense that they will face all year in 2012.

    I just think our future is bright, and this is when I had always envisioned our future to begin [2012], where as 2010 and 2011 were gathering the seeds, planting them, watering them, and now we get to see what we've been growing come to fruition.

    This post was edited by BushidoNole on 3/12/2012 at 12:50 AM

    signature image

    BushidoNole

  • I see what you're saying. UF is in a situation now that FSU was 2 years back. We shall see what Jimbo does over the next few years, but IMO at this time, Hamilton>Jimbo. Obviously if Jimbo wins the ACC next year, that will change.

    signature image signature image signature image

    It's Great to be a Florida Gator! Recruit. Develop. Perform.

    gatordmb89

  • I think Leonard Hamilton is only the beginning to the Seminoles overall athletic success for 2012.

    Our baseball team is presently ranked No.8 in the USA TODAY/ESPN Top 25. We're 14-1 right now, and will likely move up from No.8. I think we have a very good shot at another ACC Championship in baseball. The pitching staff has looked good through 15 games (2.84 ERA), and Boyd and Ramsey are two of the best hitters in the country.

    The track program will win another National Championship. That's all that needs to be said. National Championship, again.

    Then the icing on the cake will be Florida State's football season. Hopefully the icing tastes good (ACC Championship, BCS bowl, etc).

    And not that anyone cares, but our ladies soccer team will be the shit again (ACC Champs, Final 4 last season)

    signature image

    BushidoNole

  • to early to judge jimbo... he has been our head coach for two years while hamilton has been at fsu for ten

    with that said Bob Braman >>> Jimbo/Hamilton/Martin

    signature image signature image

    swizz

  • Ham has had ten years to build this basketball program where it is now, because the previous coach left him with a pile of svit to work with. Also it is a little early to judge jimbo right now, because 2012 is the year most fans had pegged.

    signature image signature image signature image

    duvalnole

  • swizz said...

    to early to judge jimbo... he has been our head coach for two years while hamilton has been at fsu for ten

    with that said Bob Braman >>> Jimbo/Hamilton/Martin

    Yes Bob braman is our best coach right now and I believe he ran collegiate at uf.

    signature image signature image signature image

    duvalnole

  • Interesting thread

    Hard to disagree with anything Bushido said

    I certainly don't think its fair to judge Jimbo yet

    He had to clean a giant mess and last year was a very young team coupled with insane amounts of injuries

    My instinct says Jimbo is a better coach and will accomplish a lot more than Hamilton ever will

    I doubt it takes Jimbo 10 years to win one ACC title

    This post was edited by NoVaNoles on 3/12/2012 at 3:28 AM

    signature image signature image signature image

    NoVaNoles

  • Are you shocked that a Gator fan is trying to compare 2 years to ten years in 2 completely different sports?

    signature image signature image signature image

    WillyDees

  • rms02d said...

    Jimbo has been headcoach for two years. Hamilton has been head coach for about a decade or so.

    Also Hamilton has been a headcoach for like 30 years or so.

    Stupid thread.

    It takes a stupid person to completely dismiss the dispersion in competition. It should take longer for FSU to build up a basketball program in the ACC, than a football program.

    signature image signature image signature image

    It's Great to be a Florida Gator! Recruit. Develop. Perform.

    gatordmb89

  • WillyDees said...

    Are you shocked that a Gator fan is trying to compare 2 years to ten years in 2 completely different sports?

    Nothing wrong with comparing programs and their success.

    signature image signature image signature image

    It's Great to be a Florida Gator! Recruit. Develop. Perform.

    gatordmb89

  • Jimbo is building a foundation for a long run at a high level. He may not have yielded immediate success by some standards (I think he has clearly improved the program) yet but it's what he's building towards and the way he is doing it that impresses me.

    TNoles813

  • Weak flame. Jimbo has 19 wins in two years. Our best team since 2001 on paper returns.

    fsufsu

  • Right now Coach Ham has done more. Jimbo's time is coming, maybe very soon.

    styancey