Online Now 3092

The Blue Board

We aren't just committed to college football; we're early enrolling in it.

On this Board 2356
Record: 7394 (2/14/2012)

Online now 3057
Record: 18710 (2/25/2012)

Boards ▾

The Blue Board

We aren't just committed to college football; we're early enrolling in it.

247Rumors

College football scuttlebutt and scoop- powered by Football Rumor Mill

The Green Board

Where the madness isn't just in March.

Big Ten Board (Beta)

Reply

If you get a degree in Art you probably won't get a job

  • VegasTide said...

    How so? Please explain because I couldn't disagree more.

    ...really? Because the market is colluding to force young people to give away their labor for free. For-profit enterprises calling 20+ hours/week of coffee pouring and paper pushing "a learning experience" so they can get away with a ridiculous system of exploitation that would be illegal in any other context.

    Not to mention how the unpaid internship system contributes to the plutocratization (is that a word? do i care?) of our society. Kids from less affluent backgrounds who have to work paying jobs to support themselves while in college are shut out from the unpaid internship system because they simply can't afford to participate. In turn, this means those kids have a much harder time finding good jobs right out of college, which dampens their lifetime earning potential...and around and around the vicious circle goes.

    inuyesta

  • CWEBB said...

    Not flaming but could you explain this? Someone told me this last year, but I thought they were just trying to disparage me from going into law.

    stoptothink is exaggerating both about how good it used to be back in the day and how bad it is now. You can still get a BigLaw gig out of a non top-14 school (and fwiw they pay 160+ now), you're just going to need to finish either in the top 25% of your class (for schools ranked in the 25-40ish range) or at the very tippy-top of your class (anywhere ranked worse than like 50th). On the other hand, going to a top school (at least, outside the top 3 schools) is not a guarantee of a BigLaw job either...you still pretty much have to finish in the top 50% of the class at the top schools too.

    fwiw I'm a 1L at Columbia, so I can answer any questions you/anyone else might have about law school.

    inuyesta

  • inuyesta said...

    stoptothink is exaggerating both about how good it used to be back in the day and how bad it is now. You can still get a BigLaw gig out of a non top-14 school (and fwiw they pay 160+ now), you're just going to need to finish either in the top 25% of your class (for schools ranked in the 25-40ish range) or at the very tippy-top of your class (anywhere ranked worse than like 50th). On the other hand, going to a top school (at least, outside the top 3 schools) is not a guarantee of a BigLaw job either...you still pretty much have to finish in the top 50% of the class at the top schools too.

    fwiw I'm a 1L at Columbia, so I can answer any questions you/anyone else might have about law school.

    Thanks. The only question I do have, is what did you major in and what would be some good majors to get into Law School? Most people have told me that it really doesn’t matter as long as it’s something that you can get good grades in.

    I have been thinking about either History or Psychology.

    signature image signature image signature image

    CWEBB

  • inuyesta said...

    ...really? Because the market is colluding to force young people to give away their labor for free. For-profit enterprises calling 20+ hours/week of coffee pouring and paper pushing "a learning experience" so they can get away with a ridiculous system of exploitation that would be illegal in any other context.

    Not to mention how the unpaid internship system contributes to the plutocratization (is that a word? do i care?) of our society. Kids from less affluent backgrounds who have to work paying jobs to support themselves while in college are shut out from the unpaid internship system because they simply can't afford to participate. In turn, this means those kids have a much harder time finding good jobs right out of college, which dampens their lifetime earning potential...and around and around the vicious circle goes.

    Yet another reason to go into Engineering. Engineering interns are usually paid a pretty good wage. When I graduated, in 2002 right after all the IT crashes and right after 9/11, it took me a year and a half to find a job.

    I think I might encourage my kids to pick up a trade like plumbing. Plumbers never have trouble getting work.

    We are both atheists. When you understand why you dismiss all the other possible gods, you will understand why I dismiss yours

    OmegaBuckeye

  • I can't figure out individuals fascination with law school. I have about 4 friends that will be graduating this year, probably with 200K in debt, and there is no way all of them will be able to find a job. The market is inflated.

    Just like 10 years ago when everyone under the sun got their real estate license and thought they were going to make hundreds of thousands of dollars. Well the only difference is that law school is way more expensive, and there are not enough jobs to go around.

    I guess if you are going to go, make sure you attend a top 15 institution.

    This post was edited by Clemson on 4/10/2012 at 6:56 AM

    The Law School Bubble

    http://thebestcolleges.org/law_school_bubble/

    thebestcolleges.org
    signature image signature image signature image

    Clemson

  • Maybe it's different in undergrad, but all of my grad school professors tell me never to take an unpaid internship. It's along the same lines as never doing freelance design work for free: it depreciates the value not only of my work but everyone else's like mine in my field.

    signature image signature image signature image

    sf2k4

  • sf2k4 said...

    Maybe it's different in undergrad, but all of my grad school professors tell me never to take an unpaid internship. It's along the same lines as never doing freelance design work for free: it depreciates the value not only of my work but everyone else's like mine in my field.

    Coincidentally, my APR professors at Bama bent over backwards to engineer a way for me to receive academic credit for an unpaid internship as a grad student. I guess it depends on where you're interning, and if there is a chance at creating some sort of relationship/pipeline of talent for your school.

    My internship paid off over a year after the fact, but I had to volunteer and work for free within the field to eventually land the job I have.

    Ulysses McGill

  • Ulysses McGill said...

    Coincidentally, my APR professors at Bama bent over backwards to engineer a way for me to receive academic credit for an unpaid internship as a grad student. I guess it depends on where you're interning, and if there is a chance at creating some sort of relationship/pipeline of talent for your school.

    My internship paid off over a year after the fact, but I had to volunteer and work for free within the field to eventually land the job I have.

    I'm in the APR Masters program now at Bama. Small world.

    signature image signature image signature image

    sf2k4

  • CWEBB said...

    Thanks. The only question I do have, is what did you major in and what would be some good majors to get into Law School? Most people have told me that it really doesn’t matter as long as it’s something that you can get good grades in.

    I have been thinking about either History or Psychology.

    Yeah, what major you do really doesn't matter for law school admissions. Most law students have some sort of liberal arts undergrad degree and they're all treated the same by admissions offices. Either History or Psychology would be completely fine...If I had to choose, I would probably lean toward History in your shoes because that strikes me as a more reading-intensive field, But yeah, the quality of your numbers (GPA and LSAT score) are about 90% of the game in law school admissions. If you can manage a 3.6 and a 170 then you're in pretty good shape for the bottom half of the top-14 law schools, anything above those two numbers puts additional schools into range and puts scholarship $ on the table from the lower ranked ones.

    inuyesta

  • Clemson said...

    I can't figure out individuals fascination with law school. I have about 4 friends that will be graduating this year, probably with 200K in debt, and there is no way all of them will be able to find a job. The market is inflated.

    Just like 10 years ago when everyone under the sun got their real estate license and thought they were going to make hundreds of thousands of dollars. Well the only difference is that law school is way more expensive, and there are not enough jobs to go around.

    I guess if you are going to go, make sure you attend a top 15 institution.

    Yeah, law schools graduate about 45,000 JDs every year but there are only 30,000 openings for first-year lawyers each year. It's a ridiculous situation, and a lot of these schools are actively defrauding their students by lying about what sort of job prospects their school can provide.

    inuyesta

  • inuyesta said...

    stoptothink is exaggerating both about how good it used to be back in the day and how bad it is now. You can still get a BigLaw gig out of a non top-14 school (and fwiw they pay 160+ now), you're just going to need to finish either in the top 25% of your class (for schools ranked in the 25-40ish range) or at the very tippy-top of your class (anywhere ranked worse than like 50th). On the other hand, going to a top school (at least, outside the top 3 schools) is not a guarantee of a BigLaw job either...you still pretty much have to finish in the top 50% of the class at the top schools too.

    fwiw I'm a 1L at Columbia, so I can answer any questions you/anyone else might have about law school.

    Law is far from a sure thing right now. Unless you graduate from a good school and at least the top half of your class, your chances of finding a job(unless you want to go on your own way) are slim. I personally work with 4 recent (last 4yrs)graduates of U of Houston law school; 2 are my data entry slaves, 1 is a bottom-rung IT guy, and the other is teaching pre-k. 1 of my roommates graduated near the top of his class from BYU law school(not a top notch school, but decent) and was on the law review, he totally gave up looking for jobs in the field and is now using his undergrad(physics) as an entry-level geophysicist for an oil company. The market is completely oversatturated http://www.lawschoolscam.blogspot.com/

    Most lawyers today would tell you to pursue something else.

    This post was edited by stoptothink on 4/10/2012 at 11:35 AM

    stoptothink

  • stoptothink said...

    Law is far from a sure thing right now. Unless you graduate from a good school and at least the top half of your class, your chances of finding a job(unless you want to go on your own way) are slim. I personally work with 4 recent (last 4yrs)graduates of U of Houston law school; 2 are my data entry slaves, 1 is a bottom-rung IT guy, and the other is teaching pre-k. 1 of my roommates graduated near the top of his class from BYU law school(not a top notch school, but decent) and was on the law review, he totally gave up looking for jobs in the field and is now using his undergrad(physics) as an entry-level geophysicist for an oil company. The market is completely oversatturated http://www.lawschoolscam.blogspot.com/

    I guarantee if you talked to lawyers today, most would tell you to pursue something else.

    I'm not sure why you think I'm disagreeing with your overall point. U of Houston and BYU are both lower-tiered law schools of the kind I said you have to finish at the tippy-top of your class to get a BigLaw gig out of. Something like 75% of the students from those schools are not gonna get "good" legal jobs, probably half of them won't wind up working in law at all.

    I suppose I am somewhat surprised about your BYU friend though...usually law students with a hard-science background do pretty well because they're attractive for IP work.

    inuyesta

  • Aren't a lot of internships required for college credits now?

    Also, aren't a lot of people with degrees taking jobs where they are over-qualified?

    ButchCassidy

  • ButchCassidy said...

    Aren't a lot of internships required for college credits now?

    Also, aren't a lot of people with degrees taking jobs where they are over-qualified?

    College doesn't offer nearly the advantage it used to because (a) everyone goes to college and (b) jobs that really don't require a degree list one as a prerequisite. Graduate school is becoming what college used to be.

    signature image signature image signature image

    sf2k4

  • world needs ditch diggers, too

    signature image

    BrodieMSU

  • inuyesta said...

    I'm not sure why you think I'm disagreeing with your overall point. U of Houston and BYU are both lower-tiered law schools of the kind I said you have to finish at the tippy-top of your class to get a BigLaw gig out of. Something like 75% of the students from those schools are not gonna get "good" legal jobs, probably half of them won't wind up working in law at all.

    I suppose I am somewhat surprised about your BYU friend though...usually law students with a hard-science background do pretty well because they're attractive for IP work.

    I don't think you are disagreeing.

    This post was edited by stoptothink on 4/10/2012 at 12:42 PM

    stoptothink

  • There's way too much wrong info in this thread... I'm working now, but will be back later to edumacate everyone...

    VegasTide

  • inuyesta said...

    stoptothink is exaggerating both about how good it used to be back in the day and how bad it is now. You can still get a BigLaw gig out of a non top-14 school (and fwiw they pay 160+ now), you're just going to need to finish either in the top 25% of your class (for schools ranked in the 25-40ish range) or at the very tippy-top of your class (anywhere ranked worse than like 50th). On the other hand, going to a top school (at least, outside the top 3 schools) is not a guarantee of a BigLaw job either...you still pretty much have to finish in the top 50% of the class at the top schools too.

    fwiw I'm a 1L at Columbia, so I can answer any questions you/anyone else might have about law school.

    inuyesta pretty much nailed this one. I graduated in '09 from UCLA, and the market coming out was about as bad as it could get. My office, which had previously offered nearly 100% of all summer associates, offered fewer than half of my class. Although, the associates who didn't get offered weren't mostly from lower-ranked schools. Plenty of T-14 people didn't get offers.

    Things have definitely picked up since then, though. A lot of practice areas had to retool or just get wiped out completely, but firms seem to be running more efficiently now, and there aren't hiring freezes or cuts anymore (from my knowledge, at least. I'm sure that varies firm by firm and city by city).

    In any case, to the OP who is thinking of going to law school, if you really want to practice law then do it. But don't just do it for the guaranteed six-figure paycheck, because it sure isn't guaranteed.

    Jumbo Shrimp

  • LONG POST AHEAD!

    OK, time to drop some knowledge on everyone. I don't consider myself an expert, but I've been running the college recruiting at my firm for the past 5 yrs, so I do have some experience in it.

    First up, internships. Ya, some internships aren't paid. Typically, the internships that aren't paid are taken by those majors who aren't in high demand upon graduation. For instance, a poly-sci internship will most likely be unpaid whereas an Architecture/Engineering/Construction major could roll in 15-20/hr. All of that is besides the point. If all you were doing is getting coffee is besides the point. When I have 100 college resumes in front of me, those with internship experience move to the front of the line. We have to narrow it down somehow. Even more than experience, it shows that they were diligent in preparing for life after college.

    Second, the good ones always get got. Talk to anyone that recruits and/or hires on college campuses. The best students in terms of GPA, internships, extra-curricular activities, PERSONALITY, etc will always get a job out of school. If you graduated with an Engineering degree with internships and didn't get hired... I'm sorry, but that probably means you didn't present very well during meetings and interviews.

    Last, willingness to live or do something different. We have alot of success recruiting kids out of schools like Michigan State and various other midwest schools. Why? 2 reasons: There aren't as many jobs there and kids want to get out of there. So if you're graduating from Univ of Mich and want to stay in MI, then you're options are severely limited. In addition to that, I talk to kids who graduate with Construction Mgt degrees alot. Many of our jobs for entry level kids are for Estimators (we're a Architecture/Engineering/Construction consulting firm). They think, "No, I want to manage a multi-million dollar project some day." Those kids end up as a Field Engineer at some job-site for the first 5 yrs of their career counting door knobs whereas our Estimators immediately take home multi-million dollar healthcare facilities to work on. Slightly different, but they are in higher demand, get paid more, and get to do something where they're making an impact. So the overall point is willingness to GET a job.

    In conclusion, the economy has obviously tilted the playing field in favor of the employers. While understanding that, the top notch students (regardless of school pedigree) who are go-getters and have great personalities will likely land somewhere decent. We hired 2 entry level Estimators last year... One out of Michigan State who is now in our Los Angeles office and one out of Arizona State who is now in our San Fran office.... they're both doing really well and love it. They probably weren't "top of their class", but they were a perfect fit for our firm. Its on the students to find that fit and it may take going the extra mile. For what its worth, I love talking to the midwest college students. They have a much better work ethic and are typically in favor of doing whatever it takes to get the job... not to mention the fact that they are NORMAL.

    Oh, one more point... I grad'ed from Bama and last year a girl from Auburn applied to a Recruiting Internship we had available... she was an HR major. I told her it wouldn't work out because we needed someone long term in the role (we're paying 15/hr BTW) and it needed to be located in LA. I told her to get back to me when she's closer to graduating. Sure enough, 8 months passed and she shot me an email. If our intern didn't do well enough to be hired full-time upon graduation (which is not the case), I would've hired the AU grad in a second. I tell alot of students to get back in touch with me in a years time to check in. In 5 years, about 3 have done that.

    soapbox

    VegasTide

  • I offered full-time positions to 2 of my 5 interns(dieticians) this past year. 1 of them excepted, the other decided that she wanted to go on and pursue a PhD. The pay for our interns sucked, but I hired the one at a salary which was pretty competitive to what they would get working at a hospital and it is a much more laid back and fun environment. In many fields an internship looks a lot better on a resume than further education; it is actual real-world working experience.

    stoptothink

  • Vegas: We had a man from a very successful PR firm speak to our Ad/PR Masters class this morning. He made a point to tell us that, while we all want to make the big bucks some day, the best idea during the first 5 to maybe even 10 years of your career should be focused on jobs that will help you learn the most about the industry and give you the best skillset, NOT which jobs simply pay the best. He said he actually turned down a job during his first five years working for a firm (also doing recruiting/resume reading) that would've paid better initially. However, by staying, he moved up the ladder in a couple years and ended up with a much better experience in his opinion (the firm he was working for was much more prestigious than the suitor that came calling). Agree or disagree?

    signature image signature image signature image

    sf2k4

  • sf2k4 said...

    Vegas: We had a man from a very successful PR firm speak to our Ad/PR Masters class this morning. He made a point to tell us that, while we all want to make the big bucks some day, the best idea during the first 5 to maybe even 10 years of your career should be focused on jobs that will help you learn the most about the industry and give you the best skillset, NOT which jobs simply pay the best. He said he actually turned down a job during his first five years working for a firm (also doing recruiting/resume reading) that would've paid better initially. However, by staying, he moved up the ladder in a couple years and ended up with a much better experience in his opinion (the firm he was working for was much more prestigious than the suitor that came calling). Agree or disagree?

    Eh, I don't disagree, but I couldn't argue with it. Myself for instance: My degree from Bama was Business Admin/Marketing... but only because I had no idea what do to w/ myself. While in college, I sold knives in the Summer door to door. I broke all sorts of sales records. The ability to sell knives in a cold-call environment gave me 4 different jobs opp's coming out of college... everyone company needs a great sales team. I ended up taking the job that paid the most as a "Mgt Trainee" with Frito Lay. I thought good pay and a huge company was a win-win. I hated it and lasted about 9 months before I quit.

    The problem w/ his theory is that no graduate will typically know which company will offer them the best chance to learn more. I suppose you could compare the options by simply stating that "a smaller firm will give you more hands on experience" which is certainly true. Conversely, a large firm will look great on your resume in the future.

    In terms of pay straight out of school, I don't think taking the offer at 55k over 53k is wise if you're making that decision on pay alone. However, taking 55k over 48k could be a huge factor. Remember that the pay you start out at is what future raises are based off of. If you start at 48k, then it may take 2-4 yrs to get to 55k.

    That said, I think sticking with a company for your first 5-10 yrs out of school is HUGE. If you prove yourself and make a name for yourself in your firm, then they'll make sure that you don't want to leave. At least, thats how a company should operate. Because of this, if you decide you want to leave after 10 yrs, you may be on an equal playing field with those that are 15-20 yrs experienced. We have guys in our firm that have been tagged as "future leaders" who are just 5 or so years out of school. They are currently either running offices or service lines.

    VegasTide

  • Really good info. Thanks.

    As a designer/advertiser, I can only dream of making $50K+ right out of school. lol

    signature image signature image signature image

    sf2k4

  • Hey guys, I have a question. I'm majoring in International Affairs and want to go to grad school, but I'm not sure what I want to study in grad school. Don't want to go to law school.

    Would my best option be to pursue a Masters in International Affairs or go to grad school for business? What are some other good options?

    This post was edited by BTnole on 4/10/2012 at 8:22 PM

    signature image

    BTnole

  • BTnole said...

    Hey guys, I have a question. I'm majoring in International Affairs and want to go to grad school, but I'm not sure what I want to study in grad school. Don't want to go to law school.

    Would my best option be to pursue a Masters in International Affairs or go to grad school for business? What are some other good options?

    International Business is definitely worth a look. I would say take a gander at Public Relations as well.

    But some of these guys will probably have much better advice than I do.

    signature image signature image signature image

    sf2k4