Online Now 3380

The Blue Board

We aren't just committed to college football; we're early enrolling in it.

On this Board 2470
Record: 7394 (2/14/2012)

Online now 3409
Record: 18710 (2/25/2012)

Boards ▾

The Blue Board

We aren't just committed to college football; we're early enrolling in it.

247Rumors

College football scuttlebutt and scoop- powered by Football Rumor Mill

The Green Board

Where the madness isn't just in March.

Big Ten Board (Beta)

Reply

MJ vs. Lebron in their primes One on One

  • FSUTrackLove said...

    -And yeah I agree they didn't lead their teams but my point is about the rings argument. Charles Barkely has none but he is better than Horry.

    -Pippen was a better defender than Jordan and everyone knows that but the media won't allow people to think MJ was less than perfect on the court.

    -And PPG doesn't really mean anything to me.

    -Best scorer? Not really, Wilt averaged 50 once.

    -The rings argument always has been and always will be regarding leading teams to championships. Horry didn't lead his team to those titles, so how many rings he has is irrelevant. Same with Jones. Again, Russell is a fine argument for GOAT.

    -He may very well have been a better defender, but that doesn't mean Jordan wasn't an amazing defender as well. He was, and to argue otherwise is kind of silly.

    -... okay.

    -It's fine if you want to think Wilt was a better scorer than Jordan, but I don't see how that's really relevant to what we're talking about. Jordan is 1st all-time in points per game ... was an incredible scorer. That's all I've said.

    This post was edited by Mr Perfect on 6/20/2012 at 6:17 PM

    signature image signature image signature image

    TURDS ALL UP IN THIS MUG. /// "2010 Auburn Tigers, my favorite team. Unbeaten in all ways." -- Dan Wetzel, April 4, 2013, 6:29 p.m.

    Mr Perfect

  • MJ would get in his head like Hannibal Lector.

    VTSmitty

  • Only LBJ fans use stats to compare greatness.

    Is LBJ great? Yes. Could he be as great as Kobe/MJ/Magic/? Maybe. (If he plays with the same mental toughness he has shown this yr, he should surpass them all).

    Those comments he made about missing his family last yr, were was stupid. Quit looking for pity points, you are not the only player away from their family during the season. MJ's father was murdered and he delivered, for example.

    Clutch situations cant be measured by stats. They're measured by heart. Until this playoff run, LBJ was too hesitant and timid to be compared to other greats in that dept. The stat that killed him, until now, was his 4th qtrs during last yrs finals. He attempted 2 shots per gm on avg. MJ would dominate those situations, or die trying. He still has a chance to be the best ever, if he continues to shut the media off in his head.

    CRgator1

  • Anyone that didn't watch MJ in his prime shouldn't even be posting. Not hating on LBJ but you are basing your opinions on what you've read or heard only.
    MJ would win. Kinda guy he was.

    free shoes

  • Bo Knows said...

    -The rings argument always has been and always will be regarding leading teams to championships. Horry didn't lead his team to those titles, so how many rings he has is irrelevant. Same with Jones. Again, Russell is a fine argument for GOAT.

    -He may very well have been a better defender, but that doesn't mean Jordan wasn't an amazing defender as well. He was, and to argue otherwise is kind of silly.

    -... okay.

    -It's fine if you want to think Wilt was a better scorer than Jordan, but I don't see how that's really relevant to what we're talking about. Jordan is 1st all-time in points per game ... was an incredible scorer. That's all I've said.

    I think we are arguing different things so maybe it would be more relevant to see what we were both arguing about in the first place

    is it who is GOAT? And my defender point was basically saying just because you are better in one area does not make you the better player. Jordan was a great defender/offensive player.

    Pippen was a better defender/and a great scorer but he is not considered in GOAT arguments because he didn't score like Jordan.

    So my point was basically as a metric his scoring should not be the determining factor in him being better than Lebron unless you are saying he is a better scorer.

    and i was adding examples of why its hard to judge situations of who is better because as far as offensive dominace as you said is the main metric you chose for being the best, wilt was better.

    signature image signature image signature image

    Walking up these hills you have no choice but to be fast!

    FSUTrackLoveFSU

  • CRgator1 said...

    Only LBJ fans use stats to compare greatness.

    Is LBJ great? Yes. Could he be as great as Kobe/MJ/Magic/? Maybe. (If he plays with the same mental toughness he has shown this yr, he should surpass them all).

    Those comments he made about missing his family last yr, were was stupid. Quit looking for pity points, you are not the only player away from their family during the season. MJ's father was murdered and he delivered, for example.

    Clutch situations cant be measured by stats. They're measured by heart. Until this playoff run, LBJ was too hesitant and timid to be compared to other greats in that dept. The stat that killed him, until now, was his 4th qtrs during last yrs finals. He attempted 2 shots per gm on avg. MJ would dominate those situations, or die trying. He still has a chance to be the best ever, if he continues to shut the media off in his head.

    I'm not a Lebron fan, I'm a basketball fan. My favorite of all time was Allen Iverson. I bring up stats because that is relevant.

    Clutch situations can not be measure by heart because that is not measurable. That is a opinionated statement because in my opinion Lebron going off against the Pistons scoring 25 of the teams last points is way more clutch than half the crap Kobe has done, so as far as opinions go that is nonsense to say clutch is (heart)

    That is basically like saying it only matters when I think it matters.

    signature image signature image signature image

    Walking up these hills you have no choice but to be fast!

    FSUTrackLoveFSU

  • dub-B said...

    Anyone that didn't watch MJ in his prime shouldn't even be posting. Not hating on LBJ but you are basing your opinions on what you've read or heard only. MJ would win. Kinda guy he was.

    Yeah, I agree. A lot gets lost in translation if you didn't watch the guy through the years. He'd kick your ass, and if his teammates didn't help, he'd kick theirs. Best combo of skill, work, desire, and motivation that I've ever seen in basketball. Of course, I didn't watch Bill Russell or Wilt, so I won't argue about them. From the late 80's on, it's MJ and then everyone else IMO. I'd rather have Magic or Bird than LJ if my only goal was winning.

    MJ >> Magic/Bird/Kobe >>> LJ

    And I don't dislike LJ, just the way I see it.

    signature image signature image signature image

    TheT12

  • Its really this simple: MJ was the most fiercest competitor of all time.

    At this time, the comparison isnt valid.

    CRgator1

  • dub-B said...

    Anyone that didn't watch MJ in his prime shouldn't even be posting. Not hating on LBJ but you are basing your opinions on what you've read or heard only. MJ would win. Kinda guy he was.

    And I watched MJ, did you watch Wilt? Exactly its like saying O, I watch MJ and because I watch MJ he is the best cause I saw it. The media perception of a person gets into you minds so easily that people forget Lebron is set up to look bad because it sells.

    MJ was great player and I'd much rather watch him play than Lebron he just had a pretty game that made you see just how fast his basketball processing was.

    With that being said I do not think Lebron is the GOAT, nor do I think MJ is. I think both are the greatest of the era they are represented in.

    signature image signature image signature image

    Walking up these hills you have no choice but to be fast!

    FSUTrackLoveFSU

  • CRgator1 said...

    Its really this simple: MJ was the most fiercest competitor of all time.

    At this time, the comparison isnt valid.

    And how do you measure ferocity? Look at people like Reggie Miller that made you think you were a bad player? What about other sports? Its not a measurable metric. I say stats because that is fact based. Ferocity/Heart all these words are opinion based.

    signature image signature image signature image

    Walking up these hills you have no choice but to be fast!

    FSUTrackLoveFSU

  • FSUTrackLove said...

    I'm not a Lebron fan, I'm a basketball fan. My favorite of all time was Allen Iverson. I bring up stats because that is relevant.

    Clutch situations can not be measure by heart because that is not measurable. That is a opinionated statement because in my opinion Lebron going off against the Pistons scoring 25 of the teams last points is way more clutch than half the crap Kobe has done, so as far as opinions go that is nonsense to say clutch is (heart)

    That is basically like saying it only matters when I think it matters.

    If you think clutch is all stats, then you watch way too much espn.

    That LBJ gm against the Pistons was amazing, I agree. But, he is just now getting battle tested. I could care less about the last second gm winner stat as well. That is just a stupid overrated stat, for a shot that rarely falls for anybody.

    You can definitely measure clutch by heart. Does the guy want the ball? Is he afraid to step up to the ft line? Does he wanna defend the opposing team's premier player for a full 48?

    I love AI too. He was also fearless, and if he was 6'8 this definitely wouldnt be a discussion, lol. If he was just 6'5, he wouldve possibly finished as the greatest.

    CRgator1

  • Still can't quote.
    12. Agree totally even tho magic is my all time favorite.
    FSU track. Yeah, I've seen Wilt, as a kid. Not the point. MJ' s will to win was admired by even his biggest rivals. If he hadn't "retired" would probably been 8 straight. Will never know. Point is, even MJ's foes considered him the ultimate competitor. Forget all stats, research his peers opinions v. LBJ or anyone else. All I need.

    free shoes

  • FSUTrackLove said...

    And how do you measure ferocity? Look at people like Reggie Miller that made you think you were a bad player? What about other sports? Its not a measurable metric. I say stats because that is fact based. Ferocity/Heart all these words are opinion based.

    Well, if you have to question him being the greatest competitor, you couldnt have watched MJ play.

    Competitiveness isnt measurable,but it is (outside of natural talent) the key component to being great. Please go get a clue guy, no offense.

    But, ferocity/heart is what it takes to be a champion. If not, with LBJ's skill, the Heat wouldve crushed the Mavs last yr.

    And it kinda helps when Reggie Miller, himself, proclaimed MJ as the best competitor of all time.

    CRgator1

  • CRgator1 said...

    If you think clutch is all stats, then you watch way too much espn.

    That LBJ gm against the Pistons was amazing, I agree. But, he is just now getting battle tested. I could care less about the last second gm winner stat as well. That is just a stupid overrated stat, for a shot that rarely falls for anybody.

    You can definitely measure clutch by heart. Does the guy want the ball? Is he afraid to step up to the ft line? Does he wanna defend the opposing team's premier player for a full 48?

    I love AI too. He was also fearless, and if he was 6'8 this definitely wouldnt be a discussion, lol. If he was just 6'5, he wouldve possibly finished as the greatest.

    Never said I think clutch is all stats... I said the things you were stating are not measurable and are opinionated. One person may look at things completely different.

    And I put stats because that is basically the only thing that translates. I actually argue against ESPN on everything. If you've noticed I would be considered a media hating hippy by most.

    I'm basically saying things that are measurable are comparable. Opinionated statements are not. That is like saying the Giants comeback against the Patriots is more special than the Flu Game. Its strictly opinion. A football fan would say this a basketball fan wouldn't.

    signature image signature image signature image

    Walking up these hills you have no choice but to be fast!

    FSUTrackLoveFSU

  • Ask Gerald Wilkens, The Jordan Stopper.

    VTSmitty

  • FSUTrackLove said...

    Never said I think clutch is all stats... I said the things you were stating are not measurable and are opinionated. One person may look at things completely different.

    And I put stats because that is basically the only thing that translates. I actually argue against ESPN on everything. If you've noticed I would be considered a media hating hippy by most.

    I'm basically saying things that are measurable are comparable. Opinionated statements are not. That is like saying the Giants comeback against the Patriots is more special than the Flu Game. Its strictly opinion. A football fan would say this a basketball fan wouldn't.

    We just see it differently I guess.

    Some guys have all the talent in the world, but simply dont put in the work to reach their full potential. Some guys are just fearless, and wluld kill to be the best.

    It isnt measurable at all, I agree on that. But, thats why it is one of the most essential factors of being great.

    If LBJ plays with the same passion that he has displayed during this playoff run, he has a good chance at finishing his career as the goat.

    CRgator1

  • Shit Vsmitty. Love ya bro but youust be trolling', or I'm drunk.

    free shoes

  • CRgator1 said...

    Well, if you have to question him being the greatest competitor, you couldnt have watched MJ play.

    Competitiveness isnt measurable,but it is (outside of natural talent) the key component to being great. Please go get a clue guy, no offense.

    But, ferocity/heart is what it takes to be a champion. If not, with LBJ's skill, the Heat wouldve crushed the Mavs last yr.

    And it kinda helps when Reggie Miller, himself, proclaimed MJ as the best competitor of all time.

    I watched him play, the question was based primarily on the fact that you can't measure that. AI took his team to the finals on his own with not one person helping him. Was he less of a competitor because he didn't win? He had less of a team.

    Lebron did the same thing.

    MJ was the best player on the best team. His team not only had the best rebounding but it had the best ran offense. The best coach the best everything. So how can you measure that against a person that did not win a team sport because his team did not show up?

    I do agree he is great but I can't say he is more competitive than a person like Wilt who against the celtics had to score upwards of 50 just for his team to compete. Its just an opinionated thing that can't be measured purely because there is not metric for it. Not that I disagree with you on how competitive he was just can't compare it to what lebron goes through, what AI goes through, or what Wilt went through.

    Its not the same situation and stats are not the only thing that matters to me, so don't think I'm that type. I understand there are things that happen that just make you feel something. But you can't measure that. That is a personal feeling. I can't compare your feeling of the Flu Game to mine because I'm not you.

    That may be the single greatest sports moment to you. Mine could have to do with track. Its just about the inability to put a metric for heart. Do I think Jordan was a better player than Lebron, yes. Do I think Lebron could have won on those bulls teams? Yes. Its opinions that can't be proven but its what you feel. Which is why I say the only thing that can be compared without bias is the facts. The facts are stats.

    signature image signature image signature image

    Walking up these hills you have no choice but to be fast!

    FSUTrackLoveFSU

  • CRgator1 said...

    We just see it differently I guess.

    Some guys have all the talent in the world, but simply dont put in the work to reach their full potential. Some guys are just fearless, and wluld kill to be the best.

    It isnt measurable at all, I agree on that. But, thats why it is one of the most essential factors of being great.

    If LBJ plays with the same passion that he has displayed during this playoff run, he has a good chance at finishing his career as the goat.

    True we do. I don't think LBJ has not been playing passionately, I just see a frustrated man feeling like he's fighting against eveyrone even when he is doing his best.

    You see something different so I respect that. And its not like I'm trying to prove you wrong, I'm basically saying its not something you just say if you feel differently you are wrong.

    signature image signature image signature image

    Walking up these hills you have no choice but to be fast!

    FSUTrackLoveFSU

  • dub-B said...

    Shit Vsmitty. Love ya bro but youust be trolling', or I'm drunk.

    Just love the Jordan stopper story. Brought in to shut down Michael in the playoffs. I think Jordan dumped 56 on him the first night.

    VTSmitty

  • Not dissing you FSUtrack but your thinking is askew. Chicago won championships in 91,92,93...he retired...no championships ..came back...,won in 96, 97,98. Same players, same coach, same system. What was the difference?

    free shoes

  • who cares.....jordan is the GOAT and this is coming from a knicks fan who grew up with a FU@K michael jordan mentality.

    jordan won with mediocre players, and before people mention pippen and rodman, take a look at the bulls roster from the first 3 rings jordan got.
    bj armstrong, bill cartwright, horace grant, craig hodges for 3, stacy king, john paxson, will perdue, dennis hopson, cliff levingston and pippen. that was jordans supporting cast when he won his first 3 peat against magic, drexler and barkley. lebron wouldnt be able to do sh!t with that kind of help. what does jordan do with help? what happens when you give him a few stars on his team(pippen and rodman).......he goes 72 and fu@king 10. lebron gets wade and bosh and goes 46-20.

    rrisher

  • Exactly VS. lol.
    Thanks for the post rrisher. Truth.

    free shoes

  • dub-B said...

    Not dissing you FSUtrack but your thinking is askew. Chicago won championships in 91,92,93...he retired...no championships ..came back...,won in 96, 97,98. Same players, same coach, same system. What was the difference?

    The System was catered to Jordan...and having all the pieces... Same goes for how he ran the Lakers....

    The 93-94 Bulls won 55 games and went to the playoffs and lost in a 7 game series to a knicks team that pushed the team to 6 in the East finals the year before that.

    95-95 They lost in 6 to Shaq led magics who went to the finals that year.

    So the team was good without him they just needed that piece that they were missing.

    When Lebron left the CAVS the team because the worst team in the NBA instantly.

    Another I want to know and this is just something I just thought about has nothing to do with the conversation. But why do people talk so bad about Lebron's decision but don't say much about Jordan's retire come back retire comeback? He was the face of Chicago too...so what is the difference? The media. The would not make Jordan look bad because it didn't seem financially acceptable.

    Now they know people like to watch the person they hate lose more than the person they love win. So the media set people up to hate Lebron. Do you think he came up with the idea to announce on TV? I highly doubt that.

    signature image signature image signature image

    Walking up these hills you have no choice but to be fast!

    FSUTrackLoveFSU

  • You cannot compare a guy who doesn't even want to take the last shot or have the ball in his hands when it counts to guys that will commit murder if the ball is not in their hands down the stretch.MJ and Kobe are on another level than LeBron when it comes down to being clutch.These false Bspn statics don't mean sh*t.LeBron hasn't even taken half the attempts that MJ and Kobe have yet he's still hit less.Bron Bron is a great player in his own right.I don't know why all these Stan's feel the need to try and denigrate MJ or Kobe to prop LeBron up.

    As far as the one on one goes,I believe LeBron would more then hold his own against MJ but Kobe would school them both.For as big as LeBron is,his post game is weak as hell so I don't think MJ or Kobe would be all that worried.He doesn't dribble better then Kobe but he's probably got the same handle as MJ.He's physically more powerful if he gets a full head of steam going at the rim than both but in a one on one that doesn't really happen anyway.

    signature image signature image signature image

    USC is a powerful place that Lane Kiffin is ruining.

    usctrojanglory