The Blue Board

I'm totally shocked they picked a pro bowl NFL qb over a redshirt freshman in college. Shocked!

Mack didn't offer

So doesn't sound like there was much argument.

And yeah, it is kind of unfair right now to compare Newton to Manziel. Even if you're discussing who would be their choice as a college QB.

Manziel better soak up all the love and attention he's getting now because once he goes to the NFL he's going to be a bust. His style of play and his size is not compatible with the NFL. Great college QB though.

Water is wet.

Lol. Just because one 5'11" QB is doing well in the nfl doesn't mean Manziel will be good? Hate to break it to you man, but Wilson and Brees(another shorty) can throw the ball with percision. Manziel is Vickish. His arm won't get him too far in the nfl and he certainly won't be able to run around like he does now. He'll get broken in half. Unless he steps up his passing game significantly he'll be a bust. I guess he has a few years to work on his craft, but his style of play right now will not cut it.

I disagree with your argument.

Or he goes to the NFL and after one day of practice at WR he becomes the next Wes Welker. He's that good of an athlete. 90% chance he won't be asked to play QB.

Of course, that is unless Chip Kelly is looking for a new QB in that draft.

FWIW, he's a legit sub 4.5 guy and he's still growing. He's only going to improve as a passer each year.