The Blue Board

Murray is more athletic and has more potential, IMO.

I'll take McCarron in the pros over Murray any day.

Is this seriously a question? Look at how horrible Murray has played vs a lot of good teams on his schedule.

Plus he is small and doesn't have a great arm.

I think McCarron has a chance to become a really solid QB...possibly an occasional starter in the league. I'm pretty sure he's hurting pretty bad right now. I don't know what, but rumors abound that he's playing with significant limitations, they're just not disclosing what it is. He has a very strong arm and is really just now maturing as a QB. I expect him back at Bama next year, so he's got one more offseason to take complete control of the team or not. Personally, I'm quite impressed with him. I have no complaints. He's missed some open guys the past couple weeks, but any Bama fan that throws him under the bus never strapped on a helmet and played the game, IMO.

I think McCarron will be drafted higher. Beyond that, who knows. Murray has ability, will just need to fine tune quite a bit.