Online Now 3680

The Blue Board

We aren't just committed to college football; we're early enrolling in it.

On this Board 2498
Record: 7394 (2/14/2012)

Online now 3644
Record: 18710 (2/25/2012)

Boards ▾

The Blue Board

We aren't just committed to college football; we're early enrolling in it.

247Rumors

College football scuttlebutt and scoop- powered by Football Rumor Mill

The Green Board

Where the madness isn't just in March.

Big Ten Board (Beta)

Reply

Of Hoke, Dantonio, and Meyer, who wins a natty...

  • WillyWolverine said...

    And MSU gets blown out a couple times a year so I am suppose to believe they will win a national title? I will take the team with the coach who has been at his school one year and won 11 games. I will take the coach who is recruiting top 10/top 5 classes. What say you about the fact that no team has won a national title in the last 10 years without a top10/top 5 recruiting class that contributed heavily to that national title team? Sure sounds like Hoke has a better chance at a national title than Dantonio.

    um has always out recruited MSU, but it's been 4 years in a row

    Excuses

    signature image

    BrodieMSU

  • CRgator1 said...

    So just say it then.

    The B10 is better than the SEC.

    Also, Mich was way way luckier to have Woodson. OSU was even luckier the refs gave them the gm vs Miami, and Auburn was undefeated in 04...

    See how dumb your logic is?

    If Miami was so much better the refs shouldn't have mattered. Blame Miami for not being good enough in the first place.

    signature image

    #FreeDevidee

    elite44

  • hoke will take more money and move to the NFL if he pans out if not he will be fired within two to three years, Dantonio is solid but not there yet. Coach Meyer easily.

    This post was edited by GoBucks93z on 6/2/2012 at 4:27 PM

    GoBucks93z

  • BrodieMSU said...

    um has always out recruited MSU, but it's been 4 years in a row

    Excuses

    lol that wasn't the point. I asked specifically about needing a top 10/top 5 class to win a national title. I see you ignored that part. I wonder why.

    signature image signature image signature image

    WillyWolverine

  • GoBucks93z said...

    hoke will take more money and move to the SEC if he pans out if not he will be fired within two to three years, Dantonio is solid but not there yet. Coach Meyer easily.

    Hoke isn't going anywhere. This is his dream job.

    signature image signature image signature image

    WillyWolverine

  • WillyWolverine said...

    Hoke isn't going anywhere. This is his dream job.

    No one has a dream job of living right outside of Detroit for very long.

    signature image

    #FreeDevidee

    elite44

  • maize&blue21 said...

    Look at it this way, Auburn got extremely lucky with Cam Newton, Bama shouldn't have even been in the title game last year, and LSU was a two loss team in 2007. Doesn't help other conferences that the media rides the SECs d*ck. If Michigan wasn't allowed in the game in 2006, why was Bama allowed in this year?

    Bama > Michigan... It's really that simple.

    JB23BAMA

  • elite44 said...

    No one has a dream job of living right outside of Detroit for very long.

    Ann Arbor>>>>>>Columbus

    signature image signature image signature image

    WillyWolverine

  • JB23BAMA said...

    Bama > Michigan... It's really that simple.

    Michigan > Grumps

    signature image

    #FreeDevidee

    elite44

  • WillyWolverine said...

    Ann Arbor>>>>>>Columbus

    Columbus > Ann Arbor + Detroit, all that matters. You ain't getting rid of that ugly relative that easily.

    signature image

    #FreeDevidee

    elite44

  • elite44 said...

    Columbus > Ann Arbor + Detroit, all that matters. You ain't getting rid of that ugly relative that easily.

    shrug If the city mattered, I wouldn't of left San Diego if i was Hoke.

    signature image signature image signature image

    WillyWolverine

  • WillyWolverine said...

    shrug If the city mattered, I wouldn't of left San Diego if i was Hoke.

    All about the long term plan, NFL.

    signature image

    #FreeDevidee

    elite44

  • elite44 said...

    If Miami was so much better the refs shouldn't have mattered. Blame Miami for not being good enough in the first place.

    Im not blaming anybody.

    I was using the same logic that he used to make excuses, lol.

    CRgator1 ●

  • none of those clowns for as long as saban is around

    btbama

  • elite44 said...

    All about the long term plan, NFL.

    My Lions could use a good coach. lol

    signature image signature image signature image

    WillyWolverine

  • WillyWolverine said...

    My Lions could use a good coach. lol

    They could use a new division that doesn't have the Packers in it.

    signature image

    #FreeDevidee

    elite44

  • I think Hoke. Meyer was really unveiled the last 18 months in Florida. He's an incredible PR guy who can recruit and motivate but at the end of the day he's an insecure, egregiously shady, WR coach.

    fsufsu ●

  • elite44 said...

    They could use a new division that doesn't have the Packers in it.

    Meh. Got to beat the best if you want to be the best.

    signature image signature image signature image

    WillyWolverine

  • Bushy said...

    Corch Urbs.

    How long until Wisky fan shows up pissed that Bielema was left off the list?

    Wisconsin and Michigan State are basically one in the same

    signature image

    Gringo Mafia Sergeant at Arms - 5 time POTW

    IrishImpact

  • WillyWolverine said...

    Meh. Got to beat the best if you want to be the best.

    Yeah, it's called the Super Bowl. Not being able to go to it sucks when you have a team that will win your division for the foreseeable future.

    signature image

    #FreeDevidee

    elite44

  • I would go with Meyer right now, because Hoke has only been a head coach at a BCS level for one year and a lot of his success in 2011 was built on playing an incredibly easy schedule

    aubie25

  • Hoak.. cbh and his staff are working gotta give them their props! See you guys in Dallas should be fun..

    act13 ●

  • UM-65% BH-34% MD-1%

    I know MSU fans will disagree with this, but I think Dantonio is a lot like Kirk Ferentz. At the end of Ferentz's sixth year in Iowa City, the Hawkeyes had won back to back January games, lost an Orange Bowl, been ranked 8th after the bowls 3 years in a row, and recruited his first top-10 class. What happened then? Things cycled back down, then back up to an Orange Bowl win, and now back down again. I expect that MSU will see similar peaks and valleys if Dantonio stays in East Lansing as long as Ferentz has been at Iowa, but I highly doubt either Dantonio or Ferentz have a real national title shot at their current schools

    signature image signature image signature image

    thejumper5

  • thejumper5 said...

    UM-65% BH-34% MD-1%

    I know MSU fans will disagree with this, but I think Dantonio is a lot like Kirk Ferentz. At the end of Ferentz's sixth year in Iowa City, the Hawkeyes had won back to back January games, lost an Orange Bowl, been ranked 8th after the bowls 3 years in a row, and recruited his first top-10 class. What happened then? Things cycled back down, then back up to an Orange Bowl win, and now back down again. I expect that MSU will see similar peaks and valleys if Dantonio stays in East Lansing as long as Ferentz has been at Iowa, but I highly doubt either Dantonio or Ferentz have a real national title shot at their current schools

    +1 from an MSU fan.

    swizbeatz ●

  • maize&blue21 said...

    You're making yourself look pretty stupid. Just a reminder, Michigan was driving for the game tying touchdown at the end of the game, not like MSU dominated them. Michigan played like garbage and almost beat MSU, once Hoke gets his players in his system, you may not see MSU win another game for a decade or so.

    Okay aside from your excuses because both teams can play that game. I see you fail to mention the penalties that kept you in the game. Or Keshawn Martin's dropped TD. We were the better team. period.

    So let's get this straight. One poster talks about how you are not going to win a national title getting "blown out". Now MSU loses to ND and Nebraska in probably their worst performances of the year. 21 and 18 points. ND was a lot closer than that but that's what the scoreboard said. Fair enough.

    The only problem with this is that a Michigan poster is referring to these losses as why MSU can't compete for a national title. What happens when Michigan loses to MSU? Hoke gets a 49% chance at a title? It doesn't add up. Let's hear a different reason other than 247 sports recruiting rankings says so. It'd be nice for a different angle once in a while.

    OTPT

Football Recruiting
Basketball Recruiting
Features
Resources
Connect

247Sports In partnership with CBS Sports