Online Now 3172

The Green Board

Where the madness isn't just in March.

On this Board 85
Record: 1310 (3/27/2012)

Online now 3366
Record: 18710 (2/25/2012)

Boards ▾

The Blue Board

We aren't just committed to college football; we're early enrolling in it.

247Rumors

College football scuttlebutt and scoop- powered by Football Rumor Mill

The Green Board

Where the madness isn't just in March.

Big Ten Board (Beta)

Reply

Matt Painter is a good coach.. but how do you think of him

  • as a recruiter? Purdue just had the best 3 year run in their history, but he hasnt really built on recruiting from that!

    OldOaken247 on twitter..... I say a lot of stuff you wont care about.

    Oaken

  • gene keady v 2.0

    Hot Sauce

  • Hot Sauce said...

    gene keady v 2.0

    This.

    I would say not quite jamie dixon/bo ryan level of march fail yet, but I doubt he will ever get the talent he had the past three years Johnson/Moore/hummel and never got past the sweet sixteen IIRC.

    signature image signature image signature image

    RO DA BO63970

  • Indiana is a very fertile recruiting ground so MP certainly has that going for him...and between the two Big Ten instate programs, Painter is clearly the superior coach (IMO) when compared to Crean but Indiana has some inherent advantages when it comes to recruiting that Painter will always struggle with. The Hoosiers have; 1) a much better basketball history (Indy has been awful for a while and they still have some national cachet. That alone should tell you something) and, 2) just a better city to sell (West Lafayette just isn't that exciting of an area when compared to Bloomington).

    This post was edited by JackTa1kThai on 4/11/2011 at 9:45 PM

    JackTa1kThai

  • RO$$ DA BO$$ said...

    This.

    I would say not quite jamie dixon/bo ryan level of march fail yet, but I doubt he will ever get the talent he had the past three years Johnson/Moore/hummel and never got past the sweet sixteen IIRC.

    yea its crazy with the team his has had he hasnt got past the sweet 16. I know with hummel hurt it hurt them, but they still had enough talent to go further than they did.

    OldOaken247 on twitter..... I say a lot of stuff you wont care about.

    Oaken

  • I honestly do not consider Painter a better coach than Crean.

    signature image signature image signature image

    Einstein

  • Einstein said...

    I honestly do not consider Painter a better coach than Crean.

    Me neither. Right now better recruiter and in game coach.

    Also just because I acted like an ass on tmb doesn't mean I'm a total ass on my board and others. lol I just hated that place and loved to piss them off.

    This post was edited by RO DA BO63970 on 4/11/2011 at 9:39 PM

    signature image signature image signature image

    RO DA BO63970

  • Einstein said...

    I honestly do not consider Painter a better coach than Crean.

    yea neither do I. I really think Purdue will be middle of the pack big10 from now. They lost Lusk which will hurt them and Crean is locking down the state of Indiana recruiting wise for now

    OldOaken247 on twitter..... I say a lot of stuff you wont care about.

    Oaken

  • Einstein said...

    I honestly do not consider Painter a better coach than Crean.

    What has Crean done at Indiana to suggest otherwise? One of the signs of a good coach is when he can make less than stellar talent play above their presumed/expected level of achievement. I haven't seen that at all from Crean thus far. At one point in time, most Michigan State fans had Crean at the absolute top of their wish list if Izzo ever left. That is definitely not the case anymore and the reasons for that are his meager at best coaching accomplishments since the Dwyane Wade-induced 2002 season.

    This post was edited by JackTa1kThai on 4/11/2011 at 9:51 PM

    JackTa1kThai

  • I mean Crean walked into what I consider the dark ages of Hoosier basketball, what he's doing right now is borderline miracle work. He did recruit and build that team with Wade, so he has to get credit for that. He also had five 20 plus win season and five tournament births at Marquette even though only twice did he advance past the first round. On the flip side Painter has never gotten past the Sweet 16 and his results at Purdue are slightly worse than Crean at Marquette. I think Crean should be applauded for his work at IU right now instead of it being a knock on him, but that's just my personal opinion I suppose.

    signature image signature image signature image

    Einstein

  • If Hummel played this year Purdue would have no doubt made the sweet 16. Final four team IMO (well of course this year no one could predict what would happen)

    GiantsNTerps

  • If Hummel played and Kyrie was healthy all year, those would have been the top two front runners by a large margin in my opinion.

    signature image signature image signature image

    Einstein

  • RO$$ DA BO$$ said...

    Me neither. Right now better recruiter and in game coach.

    If you are suggesting Painter is a better recruiter you are way off base. Painter had a full year in advance to recruit his great class as coach in waiting. He has not delivered much after that. Purdue had an opportunity to farther distance it's self from IU by following up his exceptional class with more outstanding talent and from the looks of things he failed to do so. Crean had a high school JV team his 1st year. So his first priority was to fill out a roster which he did. I have questioned his players will and heart but to a man they have been outmatched with a complete lack of post players. Not to mention that Creek biggest recruit for Crean before Zeller has had two serious knee injuries the past two years. I think if you were to check out IU's recruits through 2014 you would not suggest that he has been unable to recruit. He took over a program rebuilding effort that has never been seen on the college level. IMO.

    signature image

    star69

  • I think Crean is lights out the better recruiter.

    signature image signature image signature image

    Einstein

  • Crean s a better recruiter by far. I think he is a better coach as well. He took on a mess and his teams have gotten better each year.

    OldOaken247 on twitter..... I say a lot of stuff you wont care about.

    Oaken

  • star69 said...

    If you are suggesting Painter is a better recruiter you are way off base. Painter had a full year in advance to recruit his great class as coach in waiting. He has not delivered much after that. Purdue had an opportunity to farther distance it's self from IU by following up his exceptional class with more outstanding talent and from the looks of things he failed to do so. Crean had a high school JV team his 1st year. So his first priority was to fill out a roster which he did. I have questioned his players will and heart but to a man they have been outmatched with a complete lack of post players. Not to mention that Creek biggest recruit for Crean before Zeller has had two serious knee injuries the past two years. I think if you were to check out IU's recruits through 2014 you would not suggest that he has been unable to recruit. He took over a program rebuilding effort that has never been seen on the college level. IMO.

    I was talking about crean bro lol.

    signature image signature image signature image

    RO DA BO63970

  • OldOaken said...

    Crean s a better recruiter by far. I think he is a better coach as well. He took on a mess and his teams have gotten better each year.

    So did michigan under RichRod.

    bmrabbitt

  • bmrabbitt said...

    So did michigan under RichRod.

    Michigan was still in a bowl game Carr's last year. UM football was not in that bad of shape. Don't think they were pulling kids from class or the baseball team to come in and play meaningful minutes. Comparing apples to oranges here.

    signature image

    star69

  • RO$$ DA BO$$ said...

    I was talking about crean bro lol.

    My bad.

    signature image

    star69

  • bmrabbitt said...

    So did michigan under RichRod.

    What???

    signature image signature image signature image

    Einstein

  • Einstein said...

    What???

    In reference to the "his teams have gotten better each year". Sarcasm, but hard to pick up over a message board. Apologies. Obviously comparing what Crean is doing with Indiana to RichRod at Michigan is night and day.

    bmrabbitt

  • bmrabbitt said...

    In reference to the "his teams have gotten better each year". Sarcasm, but hard to pick up over a message board. Apologies. Obviously comparing what Crean is doing with Indiana to RichRod at Michigan is night and day.

    I missed that to. I directed a question at you rabbity on the Harris post. I meant to direct that question to you. Think I quoted the wrong person though.

    signature image

    star69

  • bmrabbitt said...

    In reference to the "his teams have gotten better each year". Sarcasm, but hard to pick up over a message board. Apologies. Obviously comparing what Crean is doing with Indiana to RichRod at Michigan is night and day.

    Alright, that makes sense. Haha.

    signature image signature image signature image

    Einstein


  • Thanks for making me laugh., Painter got lucky because of the Miles Brand,Mike Davis, & Kelvin Sampson hirings screwed up IU basketball until Tom Crean was hired to coach IU. Crean has now locked up the State of Indiana and pork chop will fade off into the sunset,imho. He should have taken the Missouri job when he had the chance.

    hoosiertildeath

  • hoosiertildeath said...

    Thanks for making me laugh., Painter got lucky because of the Miles Brand,Mike Davis, & Kelvin Sampson hirings screwed up IU basketball until Tom Crean was hired to coach IU. Crean has now locked up the State of Indiana and pork chop will fade off into the sunset,imho. He should have taken the Missouri job when he had the chance.

    Right now it is all speculation. What hasppens from this point in time starting with the 2011-2012 basketball season will prove on the playing floor that Crean is a better Coach and recruiter than pork chop!!

    hoosiertildeath